Walk into a payday-loan storefront and you might reasonably think that business is lending you the money. Under Texas’s credit access business model, the paperwork tells a different story.

The business arranging the loan is a broker, called a credit access business, or CAB. An independent third-party lender supplies the credit. The borrower signs a promissory note with the lender and a separate services agreement with the CAB.

The lender charges interest. The CAB charges for obtaining the loan. The Texas Office of Consumer Credit Commissioner explains that the documents are generally signed, and payments made, at the CAB’s location.

One household budget, two sets of charges

For the borrower, the practical transaction is simple: receive money and pay what it costs to borrow it. On paper, that cost is divided between two businesses under two agreements.

That division is the heart of the loophole. A modest interest charge can sit beside a much larger broker charge. Complying with the lender’s applicable interest limit does not, by itself, cap the combined price.

The first article illustrated the result: a hypothetical $300 loan carrying $29.90 in lender interest and $650 in recurring broker fees over 364 days, with no reduction in principal. Most of the cost comes from the broker.

What Texas law allows

Texas Finance Code §393.602(b) permits agreed CAB service fees, requires disclosure, and allows those fees to be calculated periodically. Section 393.622(c) says the specified CAB provisions do not give the Finance Commission or OCCC authority to establish fee limits.

Texas also does not have a universal 10% ceiling for every loan. Article XVI, §11 of the Texas Constitution permits legislatively established rates and supplies a default maximum when legislation has not set another one. Our example uses 10% to illustrate the gap between lender interest and total cost.

CABs are regulated. Licensing, disclosures, collection restrictions, and other applicable protections matter. A particular transaction may violate the law; a large fee alone does not establish that it does.

The question the paperwork cannot answer

The policy problem remains: a rule focused on the lender’s interest can leave a substantial part of the borrower’s bill outside that limit.

Calling a charge a service fee does not make it easier for a family to pay. If the purpose of usury protection is to restrain excessive borrowing costs, the combined price deserves scrutiny.

Next: Texas Reported $1.35 Billion in Payday Broker Fees. What Should Change?

Sources

  1. Texas OCCC: Credit Access Businesses
  2. Texas Finance Code §§393.602(b), 393.622(c)
  3. Texas Constitution, article XVI, §11